>>65402Yes, Zivildienst was a good thing. I know people who would have never chosen a nursing/healthcare profession had they not done their service, and a few of them became really good nurses. And on top of it it was dudes you would have never expected to be such caring characters.
>>65408Yeah, my mental leap was probably too big there. I was clumsily conflating two separate points. So first, Zizek - same baseline means personal shortcomings or virtues come stronger into play, right? And that of course directly leads to a meritocracy, because you can't blame society for your failings anymore, only yourself.
But to me meritocracy is coupled to making best use of what you have,
independently of how much you actually have. So take a tall person and a short person. Both can try to be highjumpers (because of aforementioned identical societal prerequisites), but which one even has a chance to become world class? Not the short one. But he doesn't need to be, because he might be talented elsewhere.
You don't need to get you PhD if you're a great carpenter, but you can get to great merit as a carpenter while you can be a substandard academic because you made most of what you have. Or, in other words, I will expect more from someone I
can expect more of and will of course hold those to a higher standard.
In school I once had a sports teacher who graded on effort. Back in the day I was angry because a fat friend of mine got a better grade once than me even though I was faster or something, but today I think, at least in school sports, that's a pretty fair assessment. He was fat and shorter than me, so why should he get a worse grade than me if he is slower? He CAN'T be faster, therefore he shouldn't be required to achieve a better time. Of course this only works in such an environment. I even would go as far and say that in maths your result shouldn't be the main decisive factor in what grade you get. If you have the proper way down and just do a small mistake right at the end, then it shouldn't be held against you too much.
Obviously all this doesn't apply to a job that requires a certain standard. An engineer doing faulty calculations can cost lives, for example.
As for your other point, I would certainly pay the jobs I mentioned
better, but of course that should also be a function of complexity and especially responsibility. The trashcar driver is rather justly paid, but that doesn't mean you should treat him with contempt because he's "only" a trashcar driver. So I would certainly pay nurses and other healthcare workers a lot more, and people in education who aren't teachers.
>>65411I never talked about bydlo, I was talking about epigenetics and how they work and even had this disclaimer that it wasn't entirely precise.